When it comes to celebrating Diwali with firecrackers, many people are drawn to large-scale options like the 5000 Wala firecrackers, which create a spectacular, loud, and long-lasting display. However, with increasing environmental concerns, green crackers have emerged as a safer and more eco-friendly alternative. Here’s a comparison between the two to help you decide which is better for your Diwali celebration.
1. Air Pollution
- 5000 Wala Firecrackers:
- The 5000 Wala firecrackers consist of thousands of smaller crackers tied together, generating a significant amount of smoke, toxic chemicals, and particulate matter (PM2.5 and PM10). This can contribute heavily to air pollution during Diwali, leading to poor air quality.
- Emissions from traditional firecrackers like the 5000 Wala can include harmful gases like sulfur dioxide, carbon dioxide, and nitrogen oxides, which pose health risks, especially to those with respiratory issues.
- Green Crackers:
- Green crackers are designed to reduce air pollution by 30-35% compared to traditional firecrackers. They use cleaner raw materials, producing fewer pollutants and minimizing harmful chemical emissions.
- These crackers are also free from banned chemicals like barium, which are commonly found in traditional fireworks and contribute to air toxicity.
Winner: Green Crackers, due to significantly lower air pollution levels.
2. Noise Pollution
- 5000 Wala Firecrackers:
- The 5000 Wala firecrackers are notorious for generating high levels of noise, with decibel levels often exceeding permissible limits. This can lead to hearing issues, stress, and anxiety, especially in children, elderly people, and animals.
- Excessive noise can also disturb public spaces, schools, hospitals, and wildlife.
- Green Crackers:
- Green crackers are designed to be quieter, producing noise levels that comply with regulatory standards (110-125 decibels). This makes them a more socially responsible option, especially for celebrations in urban or densely populated areas.
- They offer the joy of fireworks without the overwhelming noise pollution, which is often a complaint during Diwali.
Winner: Green Crackers, as they reduce noise pollution significantly.
3. Environmental Impact
- 5000 Wala Firecrackers:
- The large-scale use of 5000 Wala firecrackers results in extensive litter, including burnt paper, plastic, and harmful chemicals left behind after the display. This litter can clog drains, harm animals, and take time to clean up.
- The harmful chemicals released by these firecrackers can leach into the soil and water, further damaging the environment.
- Green Crackers:
- Green crackers aim to reduce the overall environmental footprint. They use eco-friendly materials that are biodegradable and produce fewer chemical residues.
- Some green crackers are packaged in recyclable materials, making them a more sustainable choice for eco-conscious consumers.
Winner: Green Crackers, due to their lower environmental impact and cleaner residue.
4. Health and Safety
- 5000 Wala Firecrackers:
- The 5000 Wala firecrackers pose significant health risks, especially to people with respiratory conditions, as the large amount of smoke they produce can trigger asthma, bronchitis, and other respiratory problems.
- There’s also a greater risk of accidents, burns, and fire hazards due to the size and intensity of the display.
- Green Crackers:
- Green crackers are designed to be safer for public health, as they emit fewer harmful gases and particulate matter. This makes them a better choice for people with asthma or other respiratory conditions.
- Although they still require responsible handling, green crackers generally have a lower risk of causing injuries compared to traditional large-scale firecrackers like the 5000 Wala.
Winner: Green Crackers, as they are healthier and safer for individuals and communities.
5. Cost
- 5000 Wala Firecrackers:
- Traditional firecrackers like the 5000 Wala can be relatively inexpensive, especially when mass-produced. This makes them a popular choice for those looking for a high-impact display at a lower cost.
- However, the environmental and health costs associated with these firecrackers can be far more significant in the long run.
- Green Crackers:
- Green crackers are generally slightly more expensive than traditional crackers, due to the additional cost of eco-friendly materials and the research and development involved in making them.
- However, the reduced environmental and health impact can justify the higher price for those who prioritize sustainability.
Winner: 5000 Wala firecrackers, if cost is the only consideration. However, green crackers provide better long-term value in terms of health and environmental benefits.
6. Legal Compliance
- 5000 Wala Firecrackers:
- Many cities and states in India have imposed restrictions or bans on high-decibel and polluting firecrackers like the 5000 Wala. Using these firecrackers may result in legal consequences, especially if they exceed noise or air pollution limits.
- Burning traditional firecrackers may lead to complaints from neighbors or fines from authorities.
- Green Crackers:
- Green crackers comply with most legal regulations, including limits on noise and emissions. They are recognized and approved by the Supreme Court of India as a safer alternative.
- Using green crackers ensures that you are following legal guidelines and contributing to a more responsible Diwali celebration.
Winner: Green Crackers, as they meet regulatory standards and are less likely to result in legal issues.
Conclusion: Which is Better for Diwali?
While the 5000 Wala firecrackers provide a thrilling and traditional experience, their high environmental cost, health risks, and legal complications make them less favorable in today’s context. On the other hand, green crackers offer a more responsible and sustainable way to celebrate Diwali, ensuring that the fun of the festival is balanced with care for the environment and public health.
If you want to enjoy the excitement of Diwali fireworks while being eco-conscious and mindful of others, green crackers are undoubtedly the better choice. They allow you to celebrate safely, reduce pollution, and comply with regulations, ensuring a festive yet responsible celebration.